NEW: “I Scream” Sandwich Bar

Let’s Make Whoopie and The Miss Cupcake are pleased to introduce a new “bar” to the menu: The Ice Cream *I Scream* Sandwich Bar.

When I first had this idea, I realized immediately that the concept was ingenius…would most likely generate millions in profit….and might even make me famous.

Except…there is one teeny tiny little problem…

I didn’t think of it….someone else did.

So, although I can’t take credit, one of my clients can, and so I created it for her and claimed it as my own.

So before i go on, Lindsay Brightbill must be mentioned for her research and development contributions to the Let’s Make Whoopie product line.

Brava, my friend…and thank you ;)

However…I did come up with the name…

because i think it’s pretty cute…tehehe

Each bar comes with a custom made “Instructions ” frame, to educated the confused guests…and entertain them at the same time.

It’s kind of like a win win for awkward parties.

You can thank me later.

Because…I know you know that I know that when parties are boring…you eat a lot of chips.

And people who eat alot of chips don’t have room for ice cream! This will prevent that…with introducing the ice cream immediately and bringing a child-like excitement to any anti-social individual.

You: 1

Awkward Party: 0

So, you don’t even need to thank me, but each package comes with individual servings of ice cream that fit PERFECTLY between two ice cream sandwich shells.

Because we all know that letting people scoop their own ice cream can get really messy…

and awkward…

And aren’t we trying to avoid the awkward in the first place?

I thought so.

And of course, there are a plethora of topping options to roll, dunk, spread, or pour onto your ice cream sandwich.

Topping Choices:

Basic Toppings:

  • Rainbow Sprinkles
  • Colored Sprinkles
  • Chocolate Sprinkles
  • Oreo Cookie Crumbs
  • Thin Mint Cookie Crumbs
  • Graham Cracker Crumbs
  • Gummy Bears/Worms
  • Crushed Cereal (any flavor)
  • Coconut
  • Crushed Potato Chips
  • Crushed Mini Pretzels

Specialty Toppings:

  • Homemade Brownie Bites
  • Homemade Vanilla Granola
  • Homemade Cookie Crumble (sugar, pb, oatmeal raisin, chocolate chip, white chocolate raspberry)
  • Fresh Fruit: raspberries, kiwi, strawberries, blueberries, bananas
  • Homemade cookie dough balls
  • Candied Pecans
  • Chopped peanuts
  • Mini candy bars (peanut butter cups, butterfinger, M&M’s,etc.)

Above, we have two examples of very traditional ice cream sandwich combinations. Delicious..and guaranteed to make anyone smile.

Well…except those that are lactose intolerant.

I suppose I could also include fake ice cream..or mashed potatoes…they kind of look the same?

Whoopie Shell Flavors

  • Chocolate Fudge Whoopie
  • Orange DreamSicle
  • Butter Pecan Streusel Whoopie
  • Blueberry Streusel
  • Peach Crumble
  • Graham Cracker
  • Strawberry
  • Lemon
  • Funfetti
  • Cookies and Cream
  • Banana
  • Pumpkin Spice
  • Red Velvet
Cookie Shell Flavors
  • Chocolate Chip
  • Peanut Butter
  • Peanut Butter Blossom
  • Oatmeal Raisin
  • Triple Chocolate
  • Soft Sugar
  • Snickerdoodle

Ice cream sandwich options above!

“I Scream” Sandwich Bar Packages

Sweet Deal Package: $4.00 per person

  • 3 Different Varieties of Cookie/Whoopie Shells
  • Vanilla Ice Cream Slices
  • 2 Basic Toppings

Getting Serious Package: $5.50 per person

  • 5 Different Varieties of Cookie/Whoopie Shells
  • Custom Cookie Decoration Included: chocolate design, color-specific sprinkles, small fondant decor, etc.
  • Vanilla and Neapolitan Ice Cream Squares
  • 3 Basic Toppings
  • 2 Gourmet Toppings

I Scream Until I Lose My Voice Package: $7.00 per person

  • 6 Different Varieties of Cookie/Whoopie Shells
  • Custom Cookie Decoration Included: chocolate design, color-specific sprinkles, small fondant decor, etc.
  • Vanilla and Neapolitan Ice Cream Squares
  • 5 Basic Toppings
  • 4 Gourmet Toppings

All Packages Include:

  • Jar/Tray/Serving Utensil Rental
  • Napkins for serving
  • Custom Ice Cream Sandwich “Menu”
  • Decorative Frame Rental
  • Custom Made Tags and Labels
  • Color/Theme Personalization
  • Delivery is Available for an extra fee (Depending on location)

One word.


Reserve your ice cream sandwich buffet date now!

Orders will be received by to August 25th. After this date Let’s Make Whoopie and The Miss Cupcake will be performing business in Italy and further mastering pastry techniques!